The 6 Best Diaper Pail For Cloth Diapers (Keeping Your Baby Room Fresh & Clean)

Can you imagine the odors that may come from the diaper pails whenever you chuck in the soiled diapers into the bin? If you’re a parent like me, you have to think about every detail, including diaper pails. Today, we are going to talk about best diaper pail for cloth diapers and list the pros and cons of six diaper pails from the top brands that are loved by parents.

It may not seem important, but what we will show you with this post is that if you want your baby’s room to be healthy and clean, you have to choose it carefully. If you are in rush of time, just jump to the last part of this post to see which diaper pails are our final pick.

What Is A Diaper Pail?

A diaper pail is similar to a trashcan, so you may be thinking, why getting a diaper pail if I can use a normal garbage can?

There’s one simple answer for this: the smell

The best diaper pail for cloth diapers is built specifically for preventing bad smell spreading all over your house.

Another good reason is that most of the diaper pails are eco-friendly, which means reusable liners or water, things that won’t damage the environment like plastic bags do.

Diapers Pails For Cloth Diapers vs. Disposable Diapers

If you’re asking yourself if pails for cloth diapers and disposable diapers have differences, the answer is no. The most important role, which is preventing bad smell while storing soiled diapers, is fulfilled by both of them.

The Different Types Of Diaper Pails


There are three types you can use: wet, dry and combination ones.

Wet diaper pail

This kind of diaper pail, as the name says, is used for storing cloth diapers in water, until they go to the washing machine.


  • It’s easier to remove the stains when you soak the diapers on the water
  • If you add vinegar or baking soda to the water, It means less smell


  • The bucket is heavy to carry because of the water weight
  • It has to stay away from small kids because there is a drowning danger.

Dry diaper pail

This one is similar to a trash can, and you can use it for storing disposable and cloth diapers.


  • It’s not heavy as the wet diaper pail, as it doesn’t have water
  • It serves both for cloth diapers and disposable diapers


  • The cloth diapers may get stains
  • Needs a liner
  • It requires frequent cleaning

Combination diaper pail

This one is not a product, it’s a method, in which you can get the best parts of the two other options.

First, you need to rinse the diaper in the sink to wash away poops or urine and then put them in a dry paper pail. After that, you can wash all the diapers later on laundry day. A wet bag is required to store all the wet diapers until you wash them.


  • Easy to remove the stains on diapers
  • No more drowning danger for you kids
  • Less smell


  • It’s still heavy to carry
  • Only for cloth diapers

Why Use A Specially Designed Diaper Pail?


You may think the design isn’t important, that it is just appearance, but it is a crucial part of the product, especially because of the bad smell.

That are three important features that a specially designed diaper pail has: Tight-fitting lid, easy to use mechanism for diaper disposal and a good mechanism for changing the bag.

Any best diaper pail for cloth diapers should have this three essential features.

Tight-fitting lid: Odor control is the best job a diaper pail can do for you.

The mechanism for diaper disposal: Besides having a tight-fitting lid, you also have to verify if the lid opens and closes easily and fast, so the smell doesn’t spread when you dispose of a diaper.

Also, check if you can open the diaper disposal without using hands. Think about the possibility of having to hold a baby while doing this. A step on diaper pails will be helpful in such situation.

The mechanism for changing the bag: Is it easy to replace a full bag? A good diaper pail like the Playtex Diaper Genie let you replace the liner easily and fast so that it does not end up spreading the stinky smell around the room.

Key Considerations When Choosing A Diaper Pail

Are you at the stage of comparing the qualities between the diaper pails? While there are a couple of considerations when buying the right diaper pail, but generally here are the top 6 considerations. Here are some tips to help you to choose the best diaper pail for cloth diapers.

Does the diaper pail control the odors?

Guess what? We are going to talk about odor control again. A good diaper pail doesn't smell. It is the main reason why people buy diaper pails.

When looking for a diaper pail, the main thing to do is check which system does it uses to contain odors and if it’s easy to use.

The systems may be:

  • Through aromatic diaper pail liners
  • Air Filters
  • An aromatic fragrance you have to add manually

These systems depend on the brand you buy your diaper pail, some of them might make the smell disappear, others mask it very well, and others don't work at all

The liners

Some diaper pails might need a special liner (trash bag) to work while other just need a regular plastic bags that you get from your local grocery store.

Here are the main ones:

  • The one-brand liner: This does not work with any other liner from a different brand, so, they are a bit expensive compared to other regular brands. But some of these liners has unique properties like anti-bacteria mechanism to keep the pail free to bacteria growth.
  • Any liner: If you want to use regular kitchen bags or liners from other brands, no problem. Diaper pails that accept any bag are great if you’re on a budget
  • Cloth bags: Use it only for cloth diapers and wash it together in the washing machine

Security of the lid

Kids can be very curious, one second you’re not looking, and they can be inside the diaper pail.

These are the risks:

Wet diaper pails: represent a drowning risk

Dry diaper pail: your kid may open the lid and be in contact with dirty diapers.

So, the best diaper pail for cloth diapers should have a childproof lid

Is there a foot pedal?

A foot pedal is a welcome feature when it comes to buying a diaper pail. Imagine yourself holding the baby with one hand and the dirty diaper on the other. Which hand will you use to open the diaper pail?

When you’re changing the baby, you will find yourself doing so many stuff at the same time that a foot pedal will be the best feature to choose.

What’s the capacity of the pail?

How many diapers fit on your pail?

If you choose a small one: you will need to empty it every day, and when your baby gets bigger, his diapers will get bigger too, and your diaper pail will fit fewer diapers.

If you choose a big one: The diapers will stay on the diaper pail for a longer time, but that can also mean potential of nasty smell to build up.

So, a pail like the Ubbi Metal Diaper Pail does not only have an excellent odor control mechanism, but it's also large enough to keep many diapers. They also have a lot of beautiful and contemporary design to suit any nursery theme.

How Is Your Budget?

I know, it’s hard to spend money on something you will only use for a few years.

Ask yourself the following questions:

Is it going to be useful for me after the baby leaves his diapers?

​Maybe if you have a pet like a dog, then you can still use it later for your pet.

How much am I bothered by the bad smell?

Some people just aren’t bothered by bad smells (not me!)

Do I take the trash out every day?

If you take the trash out every day, maybe you can only have a regular trash can, and your house won’t stink.

The price for a diaper pail can range from $15 for the most basic ones, to $50 for the best ones. However, don't solely purchase a pail based on price alone. Sometimes the features are a plus too.

What Is The Material Of The Diaper Pail?

The material is either metal or plastic. See the advantages and disadvantages below:

Metal Diaper Pails

They are usually more elegant and offer more protection from the odors.


  • Odor protection
  • Metal durability
  • Beautiful design
  • Expensive

Plastic Diaper Pails

They are usually cheaper and easier to find in any store. However, a plastic diaper bin might not be durable compared to the metal container.


  • Cheap


  • Plastic might absorb the odor emitted from the soiled diapers
  • Less durability

The 6 Best Diaper Pail For Cloth Diapers

Here is the part where we make things easier for you. The diaper bins listed below are the best diaper pail for cloth diapers on the market right now.

Whether you are using a cloth diaper or disposable ones, these containers are great at helping you to manage the nasty odor from soiled diapers and keep your nursery room fresh and clean.

Playtex Diaper Genie with Odor-Lock Technology

The Playtex Diaper Genie with Odor-Lock Technology has a 7-layer refill bag, a front-open that makes it easy to change the bag and carbon filters, which helps to absorb the odors.


  • Foot pedal
  • Easy to change the bag by the front-open
  • Additional cost in purchasing the first liners refill

Check Product, Price, and Reviews

Sharing Is Caring

Like what you read so far? How about help us to spread this AWESOME post to your friend and family? Your shout-out will help to motivate us to create more great posts for you and everyone else. Thanks for your support!

Check out this post for 'The 6 Best Diaper Pail For Cloth Diapers (Keeping Your Baby Room Fresh & Clean).'

Click to Tweet

Diaper Champ Deluxe

The Diaper Champ Deluxe is a very economical diaper bin because you can use regular kitchen bags. That’s why it has the best value on the market, but the odor control is not so good according to some mothers.


  • No special bag required
  • Easy to discard the diaper
  • One-hand operation


  • Odor control is not the best

Check Product, Price, and Reviews

Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail

The Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail is just like any regular diaper pails, but one thing good about it is the lock on the door is very helpful to keep your little ones safe. Plus they make the liners (trash bag) with 20% recycled material.


  • Hands-free
  • Childproof
  • ​Eco-friendly bags
  • Beautiful design


  • Odor control is not very good

Check Product, Price, and Reviews

Ubbi Metal Diaper Pail

The Ubbi Metal Diaper Pail is probably the best cloth diaper pail. It is the most beautiful on the market which has many designs to choose. The lid is child proof, and it is also the best diaper pail for odor control.


  • Childproof
  • Beautiful design
  • ​Doesn’t absorb odors
  • No special bag required


  • Can be a bit expensive compared to other brands. But the pail quality is a superior one

Check Product, Price, and Reviews

Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail

The Easy Saver Diaper Pail is a very nice option if you’re on a budget. It is the best cheap diaper pail, doesn’t require special bags, and it controls odor well too.


  • One-hand operation
  • No special bag required
  • ​Doesn’t absorb odors
  • Affordable


  • No design which they should make it look better

Check Product, Price, and Reviews

Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer

The Munchkin Step Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer is designed with a childproof lid and has a special compartment for you to pour in some baking soda to contain the nasty odor within the bin.

Quite some parents commented that this diaper bin is one the of the best diaper pail for cloth diapers and disposable diapers


  • Easy to empty bag
  • Childproof
  • Special fighting odor system – a baking soda dispenser


  • You have to use both hands when making the disposal of a diaper

Check Product, Price, and Reviews

And the Best Diaper Pails Are?

It is not about the look, but the functionality. When it comes to diaper pail, controlling odor is the top priority. With that in mind, the choice is clear. One brand stood out and that is the Munchkin Step Diaper Pail. The odor control powered by Arm & Hammer is a big plus to make sure your baby room stay fresh all the time.

However, if budget is a concern, then the Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail is a good choice. But if you are looking for a stylish and yet contemporary diaper pail to match your well-decorated nursery, then the Ubbi Metal Diaper Pail is definitely your best choice.

We hope that this post has helped you to decide to pick the best diaper pail for cloth diapers. If you think we miss out any good diaper bins, let us know by commenting it below.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments